ITOT vs VTI – Comparing Expense Ratios & Performance

Updated June 24, 2024

When it comes to building a resilient investment strategy, the smart allocation of assets across a variety of investment instruments is key. For those eyeing portfolio diversification through exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, the similarity between ITOT ETF and VTI ETF often leads to an intriguing ETF comparison.

Both of these funds present themselves as gateways to the vast universe of U.S. equities, promising a slice of the market in a single transaction.

Whether you are a seasoned investor or new to the game, understanding the nuances between ITOT and VTI is crucial to carving out a niche for your dollars that aligns with your financial expedition.

Key Takeaways

  • ITOT and VTI are leading ETFs offering broad exposure to U.S. equities, essential for an investment strategy focused on diversification.
  • While both ETFs are designed to follow market trends, there are subtle differences that could influence your investment decision.
  • Understanding the expense ratios and fees of both ITOT ETF and VTI ETF is core to selecting a cost-efficient long-term investment.
  • Assessing the sector diversification and overall holdings of ITOT versus VTI can reveal potential advantages for one's unique investment goals.
  • Considerations of liquidity and trading volumes play a pivotal role in achieving optimal trade execution and minimizing cost impacts.

Subscribe To Top Investment Newsletters:

Pricing: $35/month

Pricing: $199/year

Pricing: $499/year

Understanding ITOT and VTI ETFs

In today's investment landscape, total stock market ETFs like ITOT and VTI have become foundational components for investors seeking market-wide exposure through equity ETFs. These investment vehicles are pivotal for crafting a diversified portfolio that can weather market fluctuations.

Below, we delve into the specifics of each fund and the role diversification plays in ETF investments.

What is ITOT?

The iShares Core S&P Total U.S. Stock Market ETF, known as ITOT, offers investors a route to own shares across the entire U.S. equity market by tracking the S&P Total Market Index. This ITOT index includes a wide array of companies from various sectors, representing a holistic picture of the stock market and thereby assisting investors in achieving comprehensive investment diversification.

What is VTI?

On the other side, the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF, or VTI, is designed to replicate the performance of the CRSP U.S. Total Market Index. This VTI index incorporates a diverse blend of stocks, covering small to large cap companies over various industries. VTI's goal is to provide investors with expansive exposure to the entire U.S. stock market through a single, easily manageable equity ETF.

Importance of Diversification in ETF Investments

  • Diversification is a core strategy in mitigating the inherent risks of equity investments. By spreading holdings across a wide range of sectors, total stock market ETFs like ITOT and VTI lower the overall risk of the portfolio.
  • Both ITOT and VTI encompass this principle by offering a singular investment that reflects a cross-section of the U.S. economy, effectively deploying investment diversification to safeguard against market volatility.
  • Having a broad-based equity ETF as part of your portfolio can also increase the potential for more stable long-term returns, making vehicles like the ITOT and VTI index funds popular choices for investors looking to balance their assets.

Through ITOT and VTI, investors are empowered to partake in the broad equity market efficiently, benefiting from the diversification that these total stock market ETFs provide.

The Motley Fool is a financial and investment advice company that provides expert analysis, stock recommendations, and educational content to help individuals make informed decisions in the world of investing. 

ABOUT the motley fool

  • Over 100 Stock Picks with 100%+ Returns
  • Community With 700,000+ Loyal Members
  • 2023 Best Customer Service
  • Averaged Stock Pick Return over 550% (vs. 139% for the S&P)

Comparative Analysis of ITOT and VTI Performance

An insightful ETF performance comparison reveals that while ITOT and VTI share the common objective of stock market index tracking, nuances in their historical performance warrant a closer look for the discerning investor. Both ETFs are designed to replicate the broad U.S. equities market, yet they each follow a distinct index which may influence their tracking outcomes.

The iShares Core S&P Total U.S. Stock Market ETF (ITOT) tracks the performance of the S&P Total U.S. Stock Market Index, while the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) mirrors the CRSP US Total Market Index. Their diversification spanning small, mid, and large-cap stocks is a significant facet of their appeal, intended to reflect the performance of the U.S. stock market comprehensively.

  • ITOT vs VTI historical performance showcases that, over time, both ETFs have experienced competitive growth, although not without periods of divergence.
  • Discrepancies in performance may also emerge from the different constituent stocks and weightings found within their respective tracking indices.
  • Market conditions, such as volatility or economic developments, can affect each ETF differently based on their index's composition.
  • Liquidity and trading activity impact ETFs' ability to closely shadow their net asset value (NAV), sometimes leading to slight pricing variances during market opening and closing.

These metrics, critical in performing an ETF performance comparison, play a pivotal role in informing investor decisions. Whether looking to establish a broad market position or fine-tune an existing portfolio, a thorough assessment of ITOT vs VTI can guide investors towards an ETF that aligns with their investment strategy and market outlook.

ITOT vs VTI: Expense Ratios and Fees

When diving into the world of Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs), the mantra for many investors is minimizing overhead to maximize gains.

In the ETF realm, where the ITOT and VTI are star performers, the match-up of their expense ratios and associated fees is a deciding factor for cost-efficient investing. A lower expense ratio can be synonymous with increased savings over time, highlighting the importance of an ETF's efficiency in terms of costs. 

Let’s break down what sets ITOT and VTI apart in the arena of expense ratios and fees.

  • Expense Ratio Enlightenment: Both ITOT and VTI boast competitive expense ratios in the ETF marketplace. The expense ratio is crucial as it directly affects your investment's bottom line by reducing the fund's returns. Consistently low expense ratios of these funds ensure more of your dollar stays invested towards your financial aspirations.
  • Long-term Cost Calculations: Even seemingly small differences in ETF fees can compound over time, leading to a significant impact on long-term investment returns. Investors need to keep an eagle eye on these persistent costs, often finding solace in the cost-efficiency of ITOT and VTI.
  • Understanding the Impact: Both ITOT and VTI have positioned themselves as industry benchmarks for low-cost investing without compromising market-wide exposure. Cost-conscious investors gravitate toward these offerings, knowing the fees they pay are among the most reasonable for such expansive market access.

As savvy investors continue to seek avenues for strategic, cost-effective market engagement, the evaluation of ETFs like ITOT and VTI becomes paramount. The proportional scale of an ETF's fee structure, namely the expense ratio, looms large in the calculus of investment choices.

It seems clear that in a financial ecosystem where every fraction of a percent matters, ITOT and VTI shine as beacons of cost-efficient investing.

Holdings and Sector Diversification

Delving into the equity allocation of ITOT and VTI provides investors with a clear window into the construction and potential performance of these ETFs. Key to making an informed decision lies in understanding how each fund spreads its investments across different sectors and how that correlates with market capitalization and sector exposure trends.

A firm grasp of the nuances in ETF holdings analysis can be crucial for optimizing sector diversification within an investment portfolio.

Analyzing ITOT's Holdings

ITOT's holdings exemplify an all-encompassing glance at the U.S. stock market, tracking thousands of stocks across various industries. Despite its broad market reach, the ETF's performance is strongly influenced by its largest holdings and the market capitalization of its constituents.

An analysis of ITOT sectors reveals a weighted inclination towards information technology and health care, aligned with the sectors' overall market prominence.

Dissecting VTI's Holdings

VTI, similar to ITOT, comprises a comprehensive selection of stocks. However, its allocation reflects the CRSP U.S. Total Market Index, and therefore, offers a slightly different market cap spectrum. Within VTI sectors, you'll find significant exposure to the financial services and consumer discretionary sectors, which showcases its spread across various aspects of the economy.

Its diversification strategy aims to mitigate unsystematic risk while maintaining a pulse on the broader market.

Sector Diversification: ITOT and VTI Compared

  • Both ITOT and VTI aim for sector diversification to stabilize potential portfolio volatility due to economic shifts.
  • ITOT sectors usually offer more significant weight to information technology, reflecting its index's makeup and market cap bias.
  • VTI sectors extend its reach to include a more balanced exposure, making it a robust contender for an investment emphasizing across-the-board sector coverage.
  • Understanding the sector exposure each ETF provides is paramount for aligning an investor's portfolio with specific market segments or trends.

Ultimately, investors should align their ETF holdings analysis with their investment objectives, considering how each fund's sector exposure and market capitalization takeaway affect their overarching strategy. Whether it’s the ITOT sectors or VTI sectors, the key to a resilient portfolio is often found in the balance and spread of its holdings.

Liquidity and Trading Volumes of ITOT vs VTI

As savvy investors delve into the nuances of ETF investments, understanding the intricacies of ETF liquidity and trading volume becomes paramount. The iShares Core S&P Total U.S. Stock Market ETF (ITOT) and the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) are both highly regarded for their liquidity, which ensures more seamless and efficient trade execution for investors. However, variations in trading volumes may lead to differing experiences when executing ETF market orders.

In the realm of ITOT trading and VTI trading, the substantial daily trading volume contributes to a robust market presence that can absorb large trades without significant price impact. This dynamic is particularly critical for investors actively trading or employing strategies requiring precision in entry and exit points.

Here are some considerations:

  • Liquidity influences the bid-ask spread, with highly liquid ETFs typically exhibiting narrower spreads, thus reducing the cost of trading.
  • Trading volumes may vary depending on market conditions and investor sentiment, potentially affecting liquidity.
  • Market orders placed during periods of high volatility may show greater price variances from the net asset value (NAV).

When examining ETF liquidity factors, it's also essential to consider how market orders are facilitated. The frequency of price discrepancies can be mitigated by analyzing the trading habits and peak liquidity times for both ITOT and VTI. Keeping an eye on trading volumes can inform the best times to execute trades to minimize the potential impact on cost and overall portfolio performance.


As we navigate the decision of selecting an ideal ETF for our portfolios, it is imperative to incorporate an informed investment strategy that takes into account distinct differences and similarities between ITOT and VTI.

Both ETFs stand as robust contenders within the ambit of long-term growth, mirroring the U.S. stock market's expansive canvas and presenting extensive diversification. 

Ultimately, the essence of choosing between ITOT and VTI distills to aligning with your unique investment horizon, risk tolerance, and strategic objectives.

Whether your focus gravitates towards minute fee differences or particular sector allocations, making a well-informed choice will pave the way for a balanced and dynamic investment portfolio capable of weathering market vicissitudes and capitalizing on growth opportunities that lie ahead.

Jerry Garnes

Follow me here

About the Author

Jerry Garnes is a seasoned writer in personal finance. His informative and insightful pieces have been featured by esteemed platforms like Bankrate, The Street, and Business Insider. In addition to his financial expertise, Jerry is a passionate poet and musician with a deep love for nature.

Related Posts

Best Stock Analysis Software Tools and Apps

Best Stock Analysis Software Tools and Apps

RSP vs SPY – Comparing Expense Ratios & Performance

RSP vs SPY – Comparing Expense Ratios & Performance

Best Stock Research Websites and Platform Tools

Best Stock Research Websites and Platform Tools

Best Algorithmic Trading Software and Platforms

Best Algorithmic Trading Software and Platforms